Can agronomy overcome yield penalty of retained (F2) hybrid TT canola in the low rainfall zone? Grass Patch 2015 trial report

Page last updated: Monday, 7 October 2019 - 11:38am

Please note: This content may be out of date and is currently under review.

In the trial series at Grass Patch, Ballidu, Merredin and Holt Rock, the highest grain yields, oil and gross margins were from the open pollinated variety, so growers should continue to use open pollinated TT varieties in the low rainfall regions, rather than hybrids.

In the hybrid treatments, there were generally increased yields and oil from the purchased (F1) seed, compared with the retained (F2) seed.

Agronomy reduced the yield penalty from growing retained (F2) seed. Where growers choose to use hybrid varieties, grade to increase seed size and target high plant density.

Background

Nearly 80% of area sown to canola in WA is still open pollinated (OP) triazine tolerant (TT) varieties. However, breeding companies are favouring the development of hybrids in order to pay for breeding services. Hybrids provide growers with more vigorous seedlings, comparatively better plant establishment and generally higher yields.  However, growers have to purchase new seed of hybrid varieties every year, which is 25 times more expensive than the seed of open pollinated canola.

This trial is investigating if farmers in the low rainfall region are better off using purchased (F1) or retained (F2) TT hybrid canola seed.

This trial is part of a series, where the same trial is repeated at Grass Patch, Ballidu, Merredin and Holt Rock.

Aim

To investigate whether agronomy can overcome the yield penalty of retained (F2) TT hybrid canola compared with purchased (F1) hybrid seed by using;

  • seed mixes
  • increased density or
  • grading to increase seed size

Trial details

  • Location: Sanderson family farm, Grass Patch
  • Rainfall: Agzone 5 growing season rainfall (GSR) = 215mm
  • Sowing date: 24 April 2015
  • Fertiliser (kg/ha): 100kg/ha of Agras No 1 at seeding, 117kg/ha of Muriate of Potash) top-dressed over whole site four weeks after seeding, 33L/ha of UAN (32%N) 10 June.

Treatment details

Nine treatments:

  • Purchased (F1) and retained (F2) Hyola 450 TT, OP comparison, ATR Bonito

Agronomy treatments;

  • Seed size; retained seed (F2) graded over and below 1.8mm sieve
  • Mixes; 25, 50 and 75% purchased (F1), with remainder being retained (F2) seed
  • Density; two densities of 20 or 40 plants/m2

Two different commercial seed lots of Hyola 450 TT F1 seed were used, purchased in 2014 and 2015. 2015 seed of ATR Bonito was used as an open-pollinated control. All trials were sown using DPIRD cone seeders at a depth of 2cm, followed by press wheels. Trial plots were 20m x 1.54m. A randomised complete block design with three replicates was used.

All trials were sown at two target densities. The graded F2 seed was retained on a 1.8mm screen, while the small seed passed through that screen. Different F1:F2 seed mixes were prepared, using the 2015 F1 seed. Seeding rates were calculated according to the target density, expected field establishment, seed size and germination per cent (Table 1). Establishment counts were taken 4-6 weeks after sowing by counting 10m of plants, over five locations within each plot. Plots were machine harvested and oil and protein measured on samples from each plot.

Table 1a Treatments and seed information
Seed Seed size (mg) Seeds/kg Germination (%) Expected field establishment
Hyola 450 TT F1 2014 5.53 180 766 88 85
Hyola 450 TT F1 2015 4.26 235 000 97 85
Hyola 450 TT F2 3.30 302 755 99 85
Large Hyola 450 TT F2 3.91 255 754 100 85
Small Hyola 450 TT F2 3.12 320 513 100 85
Mix 25% F1#: 75% F2 mix mix mix 85
Mix 50% F1#: 50% F2 mix mix mix 85
Mix 75% F1#: 25% F2 mix mix mix 85
ATR Bonito (OP) 4.35 320 000 98 75
Table 1b Seeding rates and seed costs
Seed Seeding rate (kg/ha) @ 20 plants/m2 Seeding rate (kg/ha) @ 40 plants/m2 Seed cost ($/ha) @ 20 plants/m2 Seed cost ($/ha) @ 40 plants/m2
Hyola 450 TT F1 2014 1.5 3.0 35.50 71.00
Hyola 450 TT F1 2015 1.0 2.1 24.77 49.55
Hyola 450 TT F2 0.8 1.6 1.57 3.14
Large Hyola 450 TT F2 0.9 1.8 1.84 3.68
Small Hyola 450 TT F2 0.7 1.5 1.47 2.94
Mix 25% F1#: 75% F2 0.8 1.7 7.37 14.74
Mix 50% F1#: 50% F2 0.9 1.8 13.17 26.34
Mix 75% F1#: 25% F2 1.0 1.9 18.97 37.94
ATR Bonito (OP) 1.2 2.4 2.37 4.73

# 2015 F1 used in seed mixes.

Note that the difference in seeding rates between the two purchased seed treatments is due to differences in seed size and germination per cent.

Assumptions used in gross margins

  • Oil bonus +/- 1.5% per unit of oil (%) either side of 42%, with no oil ceiling.
  • Seed costs at $2/kg for ATR Bonito and retained hybrid (F2) seed Hyola 450 TT, range $1.50 to $4.70. Seed costs at $24/kg for purchased (F1) hybrid seed Hyola 450 TT, range $24.77 to $71.00 at high density).
  • $5 end point royalty for OP variety, ATR Bonito.
  • $260 used for other costs except seed, for both canola varieties. This included $58 for herbicides, $78 for fertiliser, also insecticides, fungicide, insurance, labour, repairs, depreciation, fuel and interest.
  • Long term canola price used of $555, which was $513 at farm gate, after cartage and CBH costs.

Results

Grass Patch Trial Results

The average field establishment for the trial was 64% This was a high of 78% for the OP variety. For the hybrid Hyola 450 TT, the F1 treatments had the highest establishment at 63 and 64%, while the F2 was lower at 59%. The grading caused differences with an increase to 64% for the large F2 seed and a drop to 49% for the small F2 seed. There was no difference in field establishment with different densities.

Although there was a solid establishment of 64% overall, the calculated seeding rate was too low so the actual plant density was 15 and 30 plant/m2, rather than the target densities of 20 and 40 plants/m2.

Early vigour was assessed by using GreenSeeker to measure the NDVI (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index) score. By 7 July (day 42), the NDVI of both F1 treatments was 20% higher than the retained seed (F2) treatment (Fig 1).

By July 7th (day 42), the NDVI of both F1 treatments was 20% higher than the retained seed (F2) treatment
Fig 1 Early vigour, as measured by NDVI

Time of flowering was assessed at the Grass Patch trial. Both F1 treatments performed similarly, while the F2 flowered an average of 2.5 days later.

Table 2 Gross margin, grain yield and oil results
  GM ($/ha) GM ($/ha) GY (kg/ha) GY (kg/ha) Oil (%) Oil (%)
Target density (plants/m2) 20 40 20 40 20 40
OP 566 647 1447 1589 50.5 50.8
F1 2014 498 423 1413 1338 49.1 49.3
F1 2015 456 507 1325 1458 48.7 49.0
F2 small 340 359 1096 1129 47.4 47.7
F2 ungraded 327 390 1074 1184 47.3 47.7
F2 large 383 409 1164 1211 48.1 48.3
25% F1: 75% F2 391 428 1189 1262 48.1 48.5
50% F1: 50% F2 417 461 1237 1335 48.6 48.9
75% F1: 25% F2 449 443 1299 1323 48.9 48.9
LSD 58 58 102.7 102.7 0.5 0.5

For simplicity in reporting, only the results of the 2015 purchased seed (F1) are discussed, not the 2014 F1.

Overall, there was a 19% (170 kg) yield loss at Grass Patch, from using 2015 retained (F2) seed, rather than purchased (F1) hybrid TT canola, a drop in oil of 1.3% and $122 (26%) drop in gross margin (from average of 20 and 40 plants/m2).

Mixes of seed produced a relatively linear response; the more purchased (F1) seed in the mix, the better was the yield, oil and gross margin.

Increasing the density of the retained (F2) seed increased the yield by more than 100 kg/ha and increased the gross margin, but did not match the purchased (F1) yield and gross margin.

Similarly, grading the F2 seed increased the yield, oil and gross margin but did not match the purchased (F1) canola result.

Growers generally use a higher plant density for any retained seed, compared with purchased seed. Using both the higher plant density and grading the retained (F2) seed, reduced the yield penalty to 114kg/ha (10%), from the initial 260kg/ha (19%). However the gross margin was still significantly higher for the purchased (F1) canola at 20 plants/m2 of $456/ha, rather than $409/ha for the retained seed.

The best yields, oil and gross margins from the trial were the open pollinated variety ATR Bonito, at 1.59t/ha yield, 50.8% oil and a gross margin of $647/ha.

graph of results as described in the text and in table 2
Figure 2 Grain yield, oil and gross margin comparison of retained (F2) hybrid graded and sown at high density, with 2015 purchased (F1) hybrid at lower density and open pollinated variety ATR Bonito

Trial series results; Grass Patch, Ballidu, Merredin and Holt Rock

These results are similar to the other trials at Ballidu, and Merredin, where the OP variety gave the best yields, oil and gross margin. The trial at Grass Patch was the highest yielding of the series, at 1.6t/ha, and gave the best gross margins and the biggest advantage of OP over hybrid seed (F1 and F2). The same general pattern was repeated at Ballidu (1.2t/ha), Merredin (1.1t/ha) and Holt Rock (600kg/ha).

There was a trend (that is, non significant) of higher yields and gross margin of purchased hybrid seed (F1) over retained seed (F2) at Grass Patch, Merredin and Holt Rock but not at Ballidu.

Table 3 Yield, oil and gross margin losses averaged over Grass Patch, Ballidu and Merredin trial sites in 2015
  Purchased hybrid (F1) vs retained hybrid (F2) OP vs purchased hybrid (F1) OP vs retained hybrid (F2)
Grain yield (kg/ha) 80 215 300
Oil (%) 1% 1.5 2.5%
Gross margin ($/ha) $17 $150 $167

Conclusion

The highest grain yield, oil and gross margins was from the open pollinated variety at the higher target density (40 plants/m2). Growers should continue to use open pollinated TT varieties in the low rainfall regions, rather than hybrid varieties.

Where growers in the low rainfall regions choose to grow hybrid varieties, expect a yield and oil advantage and possibly a small gross margin advantage from using purchased (F1) seed, rather than retained (F2) seed. It is recommended that growers purchase fresh (F1) seed, rather than retaining seed.

Agronomy reduced the yield penalty from growing retained (F2) seed, compared with the purchased (F1) seed. Where growers choose to retain hybrid varieties, grade to increase seed size and target high plant density.

Acknowledgements

This trial (15ES19) is part of the ‘Tactical Break Crop Agronomy in Western Australia’ project, which is jointly funded by DPIRD and the Grains Research and Development Corporation.

Thanks to the Sanderson family for hosting the trial and to the Esperance RSU for trial management. Pam Burgess (DPIRD Esperance) provided technical assistance to ensure all treatments and measurements occurred in a timely and accurate fashion.

Contact information

+61 (0)8 9081 3126
Mark Seymour
+61 (0)8 9083 1143